Brenda and Brent - Trip Diary

New Zealand

Feb 2/3 - Doubtful Sound

Here is a blow up of the map showing Doubtful Sound. The blue line is the overnight trip.

It starts in the very small village called Pearl Harbour, beside the almost as small village of Manapouri, on Lake Manapouri. We crossed this lake, a hydro reservoir, to the intake area. There is a road there across a fairly high pass down to Doubtful Sound. We boarded the boat there for the overnight cruise.

The cruise took us the full length of the Sound out to a few small rocky islands at the mouth of the Sound to see the New Zealand Fur Seal colony there. Then back to a protected arm of the Sound for the overnight mooring. In the morning, we cruised around a bit and then back to the dock around 10 AM. Then back over the pass in buses, back across Lake Manapouri to the town.

If you look north from Manapouri you see the town Milford Sound. This is the other big fiord cruise location. They get up to 80 tour buses a day into that rather short fiord, with many boats pulling up to each waterfall in turn. You can see as well that it is a much shorter body of water.

We opted for the trip along the much longer Doubtful Sound. Aside from a couple of small sports fishing boats and one meeting of the day excursion, we saw no other boats except at the wharf.

The Pictures

There is more to Doubtful Sound than the pictures, but the pictures must come first.
The boat ride across Lake Manapouri ends at the intake end of a large Hydro Electric complex. We got on buses there to drive the 20km across Wilmot Pass to Doubtful Sound. From there it is 40 km along Doubtful Sound to the ocean.

There is a lookout just after crossing Wilmot pass. We got our first looks at Doubtful Sound.

The day before it had rained pretty hard down there. Most days it does. Sunny days like today happen about 1 day a month, when the wind comes from the east rather than the west. Today it rained on the east side of the pass, not where we were on the west.

Rain is the main environmental force on the west side of the New Zealand mountains, with yearly rainfall from 7 to 10 metres (depending on who tells you). That is up to 33 feet of rain a year for the metric challenged (myself included).

Not for us though. You can see some blue sky up there - we had a mainly clear sky all day.

Here is our ship and a few of the passengers.

The big room just behind Brenda is the dining room. The one on the upper deck is the bridge. There are a few passenger cabins below bridge, but most are down one deck. Some cabins are doubles, some with four bunks in a backpacker style accommodation.

See that blue sky again!

This is our cabin, very comfortable. Wish our room on the Ocean Explorer was as nice.

In spite of the large portholes, we spent very little time in the room, preferring the open decks.

This is the dining room, with the captain giving us the welcome aboard speech. The crew did tend to treat the trip a bit like summer camp - they stopped short of breaking out the arts and crafts supplies, but just barely. There were a few children aboard and they had board games for them - children don't seem to be interested in nature, preferring their "Game Boy" electronic toys.
The steep walls of the sound are covered with native trees, shrubs, ferns and mosses.

These were our first views of native New Zealand trees. In the farming areas we had been cycling through, all native vegetation has been removed - mostly for the fields themselves of course. They then planted European or North American tree species as wind breaks. They also plant introduced species in their gardens, for the most part. In the agricultural areas, vegetation wise we could have been anywhere. (Sadly, most of the birds in those areas are European introductions as well.) (To be fair, it could be that there were no large native trees in the land now used for agriculture - the drier land to the east of the mountains.)

Waterfalls are a part of the beauty of this area.

Doubtful Sound is actually a fiord (New Zealand spelling) - it was carved out by glacial action rather than worn down by a river. Fiords have very steep walls which continue down into the water. That trees can grow on walls this steep is amazing. In this picture, which is a little hard to see, the trees and topsoil have been stripped from the rock face and fallen into the water.

The plants on the walls hold each other up with their interlocking root systems. Under certain conditions, one can let go and take all its mates along with it. This one probably happened in August 2003 when there was a very strong earthquake in the area - the rain has not yet washed all the remaining top soil from the rocks.

The guides call these events Tree Avalanches or Travalanches.

Looking at the top of the bare area, it could be that the rocks themselves broke away starting this travalanche.

We were in the dining room when people on the front deck started shouting and pointing. We got to see a travalanche ourselves.

This picture is part of the original - showing only the section where the trees were actually slipping down the rock face. The top of the hill is just visible. It looks like a tree near the top let go, taking out the trees below but leaving an island in the middle. This travalanche did not go all the way to the waterline. The lower section was still moving when I took this picture but stopped soon after.

One of the guides said she had been working on the sound for 4 years and this was the first travalanche she had seen. Hard to say why these trees survived the earthquake in August but decided they had had enough just as we were passing. It had rained pretty hard the previous day, perhaps weakening the root's grip.

The process of regeneration begins with lichen and mosses, which gradually cover the bare rock scar. As these plants die they build up enough "soil" to allow ferns and small shrubs to take hold. These form the soil for the smaller trees and eventually the big trees that eventually dominate the area.

This picture shows an old scar which has reached the moss stage.

The trip naturalist, quite a funny guy, said it took about 100 years for the larger trees to come back. My memory must be faulty on that since many of the mature trees look to be a hundred years old themselves. Perhaps he said a thousand years.

We travelled down the sound to the ocean - what the captain called the Tasman Sea.

The weather continued fine as we cruised through a couple of small islands which were home to some small sea lions (mothers and young, the fathers having headed back out to sea). There was also a colony of terns.

We headed back up the sound to an arm that was very calm and they unloaded the kayaks. Brenda had a go - I did not, preferring to stay on the tender which toured the area. I had hoped to get better looks at the tree and see a few birds - there were very few birds, alas.

The only danger in the entire area is the sand flea which is actually a fly and is a stinging biter. Most of the bites stung for only a few minutes, but a few on my knuckles itched for several days. As the kayaks got close to shore, the sand fleas were able to feast on the paddlers.

Several of the crew were swimming from the back of the ship, so Brenda and I actually had a very short swim. The water on the surface was only mildly salty and not really cold. We were out in a couple of minutes but some people swam for quite a while.

The fresh water released through the Hydro turbines (normally all the water in Lake Manapouri would flow east, not west into the sound) as well as the rain and the water that falls into the fiord, form a fresh water layer on the surface. Most of the water naturally filters through the tree roots and mosses and is brown - full of tannin. The final factor is the presence of a gravel bar near the mouth left by the last glacier which reduces the amount of salt water that enters the fiord with the tides. This dark fresh water top layer determines the ecology of the fiord - all sea plant life occurs in the top few metres. A similar thing happens in Finlayson Arm near Victoria - the fresh water washes over a layer of salt water that does not get flushed by tidal action, leaving a dead layer below the top few metres.

We saw a small group of porpoise at one point along the trip, Bottle-nose as I recall. Aside from this one encounter though, the entire National Park has very few animals. New Zealand originally had almost no animals other than birds - just two species of small bat. Now, as a result of predation by introduced rodents (stoats and possums), most of the native birds have been eliminated from this huge forest area.

The possum is the Brush-tailed Possum which was introduced from Australia - they actually farm them, using the fur in combination with wool to make a very warm fabric. The few that escaped have spread all over the country. They are largely plant eaters but will eat young birds and bird eggs. The New Zealand native birds have never faced this kind of predation, so have no natural defenses.

The possums are a serious problem not just for birds. There are so many of them and they eat so much vegetation that they can eat up a forest as fast as it grows. They climb to the tops of the trees and eat the new shoots, preventing the trees from getting very large.

There are large areas in which poison bait is spread to try to eliminate the possum. We saw signs on farm land and in forest areas warning of the poison baits. We saw similar signs in Tasmania, but there the target is the Red Fox which someone introduced in order, they suspect, to have something to hunt. It is interesting that the possums are in balance in Tasmania but out of control here - not that they have any predators either place. It must be that the tree species available here are much better possum food.

Sunset on the fiord.
The next morning we woke to a steady downpour - the standard weather in Doubtful Sound.

As part of the morning ritual, the ship heads for this quite bay and shuts off all on board machines. The quiet -- broken only by bird songs (so there must be a few birds) -- can bring even strong men to tears we are told. Well, this morning the sound of the rain on the ship, on the water, and flowing down the gutters was all we could hear.

It rains so much on the west coast of New Zealand that the tour companies have to encourage tourists by stressing the importance of seeing the west (wet) coast in the rain - the waterfalls are more spectacular during the rain. I suspect this is putting the best face on a rather wet argument. This rainy morning was pretty dreary, especially when compared to the exhilaration of yesterday.



The History

The Maori made limited use of the area - the steep rock faces have few places for camps and there is evidence of use in only a few places. Most access was by sea, although there is some evidence of access over the pass from Lake Manapouri.

This shipboard poster shows two of the early explorers in the area. Captain James Cook and his naturalist Joseph Banks were the first Europeans in 1770. The pass at the head of the sound was only explored from the other side in by a European in 1897.

When the New Zealand Hydro electric authority decided to divert the water from Lake Manapouri west into the sound to create electricity there was a lot of opposition. The final petition had 250,000 (60,000?) names in a country of fewer than 3 million people.

Adding a lot more fresh water to the Doubtful Sound would completely change the marine environment, especially since the water in Lake Manapouri is relatively clear. More clear (as opposed to tannin rich) fresh water would eliminate the existing marine ecosystems.

There was a compromise which limited the outflow into the sound, and limited the amount they could change the level of the upper lake to about 5 metres. Unlike many hydro reservoirs in Canada, which have their levels change dramatically between the rainy season and the dry season, Lake Manapouri looks much the same year round.

Eighth Wonder?

Some famous traveler has called Doubtful Sound the Eighth Wonder of the Modern World. I would not go that far, but it is an awe inspiring place to visit. A few pictures cannot begin to reproduce the sense of grandeur inspired by these steep mountain faces around these narrow waterways. The first hour was spent in open-mouthed wonder.

A trip to New Zealand would not be complete without a trip to one of these fiords. And life would not be complete without a trip to New Zealand!

Back to the South Island page this way

Back to the New Zealand page this way

Back to the trip overview page this way